CSE 770x Paper Review Form

Select your name:
Michela Becchi Chakchai So-in Patrick Crowley Sarang Dharamapurikar Mart Haitjema Manfred Georg Sergey Gorinsky Shakir James Jing Lu Sailesh Kumar Ritun Patney Max Podlesny Todd Sproull Jon Turner Mike Wilson Charlie Wiseman Ben Wun

Select the date:
8-30-2007 9-6-2007 9-13-2007 9-20-2007 9-27-2007 10-4-2007 10-11-2007 10-18-2007 10-25-2007 11-1-2007 11-8-2007 11-15-2007 11-29-2007 12-6-2007 12-13-2007

1. How would you rate this paper, relative to others we have read?
   top 10% top 25%, but not top 10% top 50%, but not top 25% bottom 50%
2. How would you rate your knowledge of the topic of this paper?
   expert familiar, but not expert novice
3. What problem or issue does the paper address? Why is it important?
   
   (Note that you may use html formatting tags to make your comments more readable.)
4. What are the main contributions of the paper?
   
5. How significant are these contributions, relative to previous work?
   
6. Give detailed comments justifying your view of the paper.